Which of Spain's Balearic Islands is Best?

The Balearics is a Spanish archipelago in the Mediterranean Sea comprising the four major islands of Mallorca, Ibiza, Menorca, and Formentera. Each provides a unique vacation experience steeped in luxury. But which Balearic Island is best?

Mallorca – Best Balearic Island for Luxury Food and Wine Tourism 

The largest island is arguably the most diverse for activities and is the best Balearic for family vacations. Palma’s Old Town is strewn with Gothic landmarks including the circular Bellver Castle and the stunning cathedral which sports handiwork from Gaudí’s renovation. A complex of Arab Baths also stands in testament to Moorish rule in the Iberian Peninsula. 

Travelers can escape the heat at the Drach Caves where passages weave through stalagmites and subterranean lakes. Mallorca is fringed by fine white sand crescents and rocky coves. Child-friendly beach resorts and all-inclusives are congregated on the outskirts of Palma and near the northern settlement of Alcúdia.

Seventy vineyards and wineries cultivate Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Syrah varieties alongside the native Manto Negro grape. Tours are delivered by the Mallorca Wine Express Train as well as by catamaran and helicopter. Choppers soar over the UNESCO World Heritage Tramuntana Mountains before touching down at an organic wine finca for a private dining and wine tasting experience.

Ibiza – Best Balearic Island for Wellness and Shopping

Ibiza is synonymous with partying and nightlife. The "superclubs" are located on the outskirts of Ibiza Town where history buffs are equally captivated by the fortified Dalt Vila and its viewpoints, museums, and cafes. 

Away from the bustling San Antonio, Ibiza dazzles with its plunging limestone cliffs and pine forests. Some of the best beaches stretch out from Portinatx on the overlooked and rarely visited northern coast. The natural wonders and sleepy hamlets are a recipe for wellness. 

Luxury resorts and boutique agriturismo offer farm-to-table dining, infinity pools, and daily yoga classes. Prestigious yoga retreats run year-round at private villas with Mediterranean winters providing optimum hiking conditions. Groups and families seeking additional privacy may rent a rural finca with bespoke wellness packages and personal chef hire. 

Ibiza is first and foremost a sanctuary for free spirits and creatives. Harking back to the golden 60s, hippy markets grant a unique opportunity to stockpile boho trinkets and whimsical clothing for loved ones back home. Las Dalias and San Juan in the north offer the most authentic shopping experience. 

Menorca – Best Balearic Island for Honeymoons and Anniversaries 

The easternmost island is overshadowed by its neighbors – and that’s only a positive. Menorca benefits from a quieter environment that resonates with honeymooners and families seeking a mix of culture and beach. 

Enjoy a handheld stroll around the picturesque port of Ciutadella and the city’s splendid plazas and shopping lanes. Mahón, the capital, is rich in heritage spots and a dining scene spanning haute cuisine and traditional tapas taverns. Over 100 beaches are dotted along the coastline, untouched by high-rises and amenities. Couples shouldn’t miss out on a private boat tour to visit secret swimming coves and bays only accessible from the water.  

Adults-only and family-focused properties ensure all needs are met. Mark a special anniversary at the spa suite at Bordoy Casa Ládico or get a taste of pastoral life amid Rural Hotel Biniarroca’s landscaped gardens. 

Formentera – Best Balearic Island for Beaches and Sailing

You’d be forgiven for mistaking the smallest of the quartet for a Caribbean island. Formentera has pearly white beaches and crystal-clear waters that make footwear redundant. This island is small enough that most tourists get around on foot or by bicycle. 

Apart from swimming and catching sunsets from the monumental lighthouses, there isn’t a lot to see or do in Formentera besides soak up the rays and venture out for snorkeling. A scattering of hotels offer a barefoot luxury experience, although these tend to close up over summer. 

Formentera can be visited on a day trip from Ibiza. Ferries between the islands take 40 minutes while private yacht charters are an unforgettable adventurous experience under the Mediterranean sun. 

‍Contact Darby at Darby’s Destinations to design a bespoke vacation in the Balearic islands.

‍